Paul Power listens to John Carney’s soundtrack for November Afternoon and likes what he hears
A new conundrum: “what is an Irish film soundtrack?”
Well, one thing it typically doesn't sound like is November Afternoon. Co-director
John Carney's clever jazz score and choice of recorded tracks were some of the
main elements that made the film stand out as one of the most refreshing debut
features in recent years at its Cork Film Festival screening in October.
Carney’s confident, swinging music is a totally new departure
for contemporary Irish cinema. Not since Louis Stewart’s marvellous scoring
of Briain O’ Loughlin’s 1975 RTÉ drama A Day in the Life of Martin Cluxton
has an Irish film had an entire jazz soundtrack. This element adds an extra
dimension to a film already so stylistically different from traditional Irish
fare. At crucial points in the film when a haunting harmonica call, a plaintive
blast of the uileann pipes or a delve into 70s (and even 80s) nostalgia would
be employed by other directors, Carney’s original music transports us to a setting
both universal and yet, typically Irish. The beauty of November Afternoon is
that the music both adds a continuos dimension to the story while placing it
in a quartier that could as easily be Greenwich Village, the Liberties
or Camden.
The film almost seems to be music-led, although Carney
insists that “the music didn’t come first, but a lot of musical ideas did.”
By his own accounts, “70-80%” of the film’s music is original. “I couldn’t stand
to use unoriginal music unless it didn’t attract attention to itself Ð its
bankrupt and cheatingÓ he continues, citing lazy use of music to complete
or even create a scene.Ó Yet even Carney is guilty of this himself, in
his use of Oscar Peterson singing ‘Orange Coloured Sky’ to contrast the chilliness
and effervescence of the male leads.
In an early scene, Carney, ex-bassist with The Frames,
nails his musical colours to the mast as John (Mark Doherty) goes through Robert’s
records: “Miles Davis, John Coltrane, Charlie Mingus, Nat King Cole, Chick Corea...”
“he’s wonderful” interrupts Robert (Mark McElhatton). ÒI wouldnÕt
knowÓ the hapless John replies, in a perfect set-up for what will follow.
A live gig at the Baggot Inn is the musical highlight with the director himself
on guitar, joining a sextet which includes veteran tenor player Dick Buckley
in a blazing session, topped by a beautifully haunting solo version of ‘Where
or When’ by vocalist Camille O’ Sullivan. Carney’s respect for the music extends
to his exclusion of any dialogue during this five-minute scene and indeed at
several points in the film, dialogue punctuates the music rather than vice versa.
Echoing the acting foursome throughout the film is a
rhythm quartet (guitar, piano, bass and drums). The guitar-led rhythm melodies
are similar to those of Django Reinhardt and his innovatory 1930s Quintette
du Hot Club de France, link scenes or strike up as the tone or direction of
the story changes. It's a languid feel that fits well with the laid-back angst
of the story itself as the fragile walls surrounding the four slowly collapse.
There is a repeating theme in November Afternoon which
almost replicates the opening bar in Gershwin's 'Our Love id Here to Stay',
and is given an upbeat treatment for the film's lighter passages. With, at different
points, nods towards the piano trios of George Shearing and Oscar Peterson,
Carney's lyrical, swinging jazz is the lifeblood of the film. Even the characters
make verbal references to Ella Fitzgerald and Peterson. Carney's musical heart
is clearly set in the three decades up to the 1950s when The Great American
Songbook was in its heyday. For his next project – 'The Tender trap' – the first
Irish musical with all original songs, he intends to use as his touchstone those
great American songwriters of the era: Richard Rodgers and Lorenz Hart, George
and Ira Gershwin and Cole Porter.
Carney's guerrilla film-maker approach was also adopted during the recording of the soundtrack. Over ten days on a DAT in his sitting room he played and recorded guitar, piano, bass, drums and some clarinet, getting professional musicians for overdubs on a couple of tracks. He is already irked at the film being termed cool, hip and jazzy because of its soundtrack. "it;s just music" he says. And although we have several jazz musicians of international repute living here, and a thriving jazz culture, why has nobody used a jazz soundtrack before? November Afternoon should open doors for musicians, composers and directors who may have felt that a film that sounds like this could never work.